We're wired for belonging!! We want to know there are places where we're known, accepted and connected to other people, and religion can offer that in really powerful ways. But sometimes belonging gets confused with conformity. In some religious environments there's a strong expectation of sameness, not only in faith but in ideas about family, gender, sexuality, politics and what a "good" life looks like. When nearly everyone around you believes the same things, stepping outside those norms can bring up guilt, insecurity and a very real fear of rejection.
This is where individuation becomes so important. We can belong to other people without becoming the SAME as them. We can stay connected while having different needs, values and beliefs, and tolerating those differences might actually let us build relationships based on real acceptance.
RELIGIOUS BELONGING CAN MAKE SEPARATENESS COMPLICATED
Plenty of religious communities make lots of room for disagreement and questions. But in environments where conformity is strongly encouraged, belonging and sameness can get tangled together. Being part of the group might mean believing certain things with total certainty. Questioning might get treated as a spiritual problem instead of an ordinary part of thinking for yourself, and people who leave might be talked about in a way that makes it really clear what could happen to you socially.
When belonging is tied to conformity, individuation can feel threatening, because becoming your own person means discovering where you're DIFFERENT. You might notice that a value you were handed doesn't actually feel like yours. You might change your beliefs entirely! Those differences don't mean something has gone wrong, and sometimes they just mean that two separate people are, in fact, separate :)
INDIVIDUATION MEANS WE DON’T HAVE TO MOLD OURSELVES AFTER EACH OTHER
Individuation gives us room to say: I am me, and you are you. I can have feelings that aren't your feelings and needs you don't understand. I can value something you don't value, come to a different conclusion than you and still care deeply about you. That sounds straightforward on paper, but it can be so hard when sameness is what has kept us connected. If disagreement led to correction or rejection, it makes sense that we'd learn to mold ourselves around the people we love.
So we stay quiet about our changing beliefs, soften our opinions until they're barely opinions anymore, or explain our choices over and over, hoping someone will finally say they're okay. Individuation asks something different of us. It asks whether we can stay connected to OURSELVES even when another person doesn't completely understand or agree.
CARL ROGERS ON BEING STRONG IN OUR SEPARATENESS
Carl Rogers, the founder of person-centered therapy, wrote beautifully about this tension between connection and separateness. He asked questions that I think reach way beyond the therapy room. In On Becoming a Person, Rogers asks whether we can be strong enough in our own separateness to recognize that we exist separately from another person, with feelings and rights of our own. Then he turns the question around: can we feel secure enough in ourselves to let the other person be separate too, to let them be who they are instead of needing them to follow our advice or mold themselves after us?
I love that these questions go both directions! Individuation is partly about finding the courage to say, "You don't get to tell me who I am," and it's also about becoming secure enough that we don't need to tell someone else who THEY have to be. Rogers captures this when he writes, "When I can freely feel this strength of being a separate person," he becomes more capable of deeply understanding and accepting another person, because he's no longer so afraid of losing himself. Separateness doesn't have to get in the way of connection, and sometimes it's exactly what makes deeper connection possible.
THIS GOES BOTH WAYS WHEN RELIGIOUS BELIEFS CHANGE
This gets especially important when someone's religious beliefs change. If someone you love leaves or changes their relationship with a religion you still believe in, individuation lets you recognize that their change doesn't have to threaten YOUR faith. You don't have to convince them to come back in order to feel secure in what you believe. You can grieve how the relationship is changing and still make room for them to become someone different from you.
And when you're the one whose beliefs changed, individuation asks you to practice the same thing in reverse. Your changed beliefs don't need anyone's agreement to be valid, and you don't have to convince your parents, siblings, spouse or friends that you've reached the "right" conclusion. You can disagree with beliefs you once held while letting people you love keep finding meaning in them.
Of course, sometimes beliefs directly affect safety, equality, boundaries or whether a relationship can keep going the way it has. Accepting someone's separateness doesn't require accepting harmful treatment or pretending every difference is no big deal. But when connection across difference IS possible, individuation helps us make room for it.
BELONGING DOESN’T HAVE TO REQUIRE SAMENESS
I think one of the fears underneath religious change is often, If I'm different, do I still belong? Sometimes, painfully, a particular community answers no, and some people experience real rejection and loss when they stop conforming. But the bigger answer can still be yes, because there are forms of belonging that don't require sameness.
You can find relationships where people believe differently and stay curious about each other. Sometimes you can even renegotiate the relationships you already have, so that something once built around shared religion slowly becomes built around something bigger than shared belief. That transition can be awkward and painful. It can also create a different kind of intimacy, because you're no longer only relating to the parts of each other that match.
OUR OWN DIFFERENCES BECOME EASIER TO ACCEPT WHEN DIFFERENCE ITSELF BECOMES LESS THREATENING
There's another piece of Rogers's idea I really love: becoming more secure in our own separateness can make us more able to accept someone else's. When I don't need you to agree with me in order to trust myself, your disagreement gets a lot less scary. When I know your feelings belong to you and mine belong to me, I don't have to change mine the second you're uncomfortable, and if I can survive being misunderstood, I don't have to write a five-paragraph explanation for every decision I make.
That same freedom extends outward, too. I don't have to control your beliefs, convince you to make the same choices I've made, or read your difference as a rejection of me. We get less invested in molding ourselves around each other and more able to actually meet each other.
STRONG IN OUR SEPARATENESS
This is what I want individuation to look like, and it has nothing to do with hyper-independence, emotional distance or "I don't care what anyone thinks." We still need each other! Relationships still involve compromise, vulnerability and sometimes sacrifice. We just don't have to erase our separateness to create belonging.
I can have my needs and recognize that you have yours. I can hold my values while staying curious about yours and change my beliefs without requiring you to change alongside me. The more secure I get in being a separate person, the less threatening your separateness becomes, and maybe that gives us a different path toward belonging. Making room for difference supports individuation rather than conformity, and from that separateness, deeper understanding, acceptance and connection get to become possible. We don't have to mold ourselves after one another in order to love one another.
If this resonates with you, especially if your religious experiences made belonging feel dependent on conformity, or changing your beliefs has made it hard to know how to stay connected while becoming your own person, this is something we can explore together in therapy. Learn more about how I work with religious trauma →
I offer online therapy for women in Alaska, Arizona, Texas, Utah & Washington. Schedule a free 15-minute consultation.
credit: www.instagram.com/webcomic_name
